Dundee manager Tony Docherty: "Immensely proud, but the overriding feeling is one of disappointment. I thought we did enough to win the match. "I watched Celtic put on [Nicolas] Kuhn, [Arne] Engels, [Luis] Palma.

The champions had to settle for a draw at Dens Park last night (Tuesday) against a Dundee side on a good run of form.The Celts took the lead early in the match when Luke McCowan, on his first return

Patrick: Dundee deserved the points, we were totally outplayed. When the Celtic subs came on I thought that would be the turning point, but no, we still couldn't cope. Adam Idah looks too desperate and can't cope with the pressure of his price tag. Great game, just not so great for Celtic.